Score:0

Filesystem to protect the storage medium

cn flag

I'm working on an embedded system which will act as a server, the problem is the environment where it will run is so aggressive and it will suffer abrupt power interruptions. So I'm planning to mount the root filesystem as fake-writable using OverlayFS. The idea comes from RaspberryPi, where the devs have a mechanism to enable/disable the mounting of rootfs as OverlayFS (as you can see it can be enabled by using raspi-config script)

My question is ... would this help to protect the physical device from corruption? Or even the filesystem itself? My idea is to extend the life of the physical device and I think I can do this avoiding write operations, but the system cannot be purely read-only because some programs need to see the FS as writable, that's why I'm thinking in OverlayFS.

What do you think? Do you have some other idea on how to tackle this problem? Thank you all.

PS: The system I have to use is Debian Buster.

Score:2
cn flag

Writes still happen, overlayfs redirects them into the upper layer. And the lower layer will need to be updated eventually. So no, just having an overlay won't fix a challenge with durability. You should think about what data needs to be durable, and how to recover from failure.

Power off during write risks data being lost somewhere in the several layers of file system, block, and storage media. Good file systems have a journal for metadata so they will survive, but may lose data. Test this by powering off a device while in use, check if data integrity is maintained.

That raspi-config appears to have upper on tmpfs, so yes avoids wear on storage media, but writes would be lost on reboot! Which might be acceptable in some use cases, reboot and it returns to a known state.

Data that needs to be preserved could be sent elsewhere, for example syslog forwarding to a central logging server on stable power. Or posting data to some remote API. Or saved to a local data partition separate from the volume with the installed software.

Speaking of stable power, an uninterruptable power supply is an excellent investment if power is unreliable. A relatively small battery is enough to gracefully shut down if power is cut.

Regarding the lower layer, upgrading the software is an operation that must be successful for the device to still function. Consider image based updates, such as the SWUpdate embedded device updater (or Ubuntu image upgrades or Fedora IoT, several to choose from). A dual image with recovery is worth studying even if not implemented for this project.

jfernandz avatar
cn flag
"That raspi-config appears to have upper on tmpfs, so yes avoids wear on storage media, but writes would be lost on reboot!" I think I can deal with this because of the nature of the system (it doesn't need much persistence, just a couple of files which as you said ... they can be stored in a separate partition). Thank you for the clarification!
mangohost

Post an answer

Most people don’t grasp that asking a lot of questions unlocks learning and improves interpersonal bonding. In Alison’s studies, for example, though people could accurately recall how many questions had been asked in their conversations, they didn’t intuit the link between questions and liking. Across four studies, in which participants were engaged in conversations themselves or read transcripts of others’ conversations, people tended not to realize that question asking would influence—or had influenced—the level of amity between the conversationalists.