Split initrd into smaller files

jbbletterman

1/17/23, 8:54 AM

I would like to know if it's possible to have a split initrd implementation. Our reason for doing this, is the fact that our Fedora based application uses a stripped version of Fedora underneath with an initrd file which has become so large (+500MB), that GRUB2 is giving us issues with said file on some computers (mainly cheap HP laptops our clients love to buy against our recommendations). We have established that the problem lies with GRUB2, initrd and HP laptops, because unpacking initrd allows these machines to boot. For our use case, however, we need to be able to boot into RAM, because our application is a bootable RAMDisk which runs our app in a kiosk environment.

We are already using the highest form of compression on initrd (XZ level 9). Serving the rootfs from a network share and forcing our clients to adjust their infrastructure is an undesirable solution. We would like to keep the option for our application to simply boot off a USB device, like they are already doing.

Diverging from GRUB2 would perhaps also be an option, but that would jeopardize our ability to be bootable on EFI-only Secure Boot enabled hardware (because GRUB2 packages are presigned by some vendors for Secure Boot).

Is it possible to simply split up our massive initrd? Or do we have other options?

Thank you.

EDIT: Unfortunately, we need to supply as many modules as possible. This image needs to be portable on as many different types of devices as possible, to reduce the chances of clients running into kernel panics.

0 + 0

fedora

usb

grub

ramdisk

initramfs

Tero Kilkanen

1/18/23, 7:51 PM

Have you tried removing not needed elements from initrd?

jbbletterman

1/20/23, 8:02 AM

Unfortunately, we need to supply as many modules as possible. This image needs to be portable on as many different types of devices as possible, to reduce the chances of clients running into kernel panics.

Tero Kilkanen

1/20/23, 2:17 PM

I think there might be kernel subsystems that you don't need for your product, and you could disable those.

Michael Hampton

1/25/23, 11:00 PM

You should look at the list of modules in dracut on the OS installation media. For the purpose of hardware compatibility it is unlikely you'll need much (or any) more of those.

jbbletterman

1/27/23, 10:47 AM

Michael Hampton

1/27/23, 10:55 AM

So does the installation media. It also has to run on as many devices as possible. It's really worth a look before you just dismiss it out of hand.

jbbletterman

1/27/23, 10:59 AM

Removing modules in Dracut on the OS installation media will increase hardware compatibility with more systems? You're going to have to explain this to me.

Elon Musk

I sit in a Tesla and translated this thread with Ai:

EN: Split initrd into smaller files

TH: แยก initrd ออกเป็นไฟล์ขนาดเล็ก

RO: Împărțiți initrd în fișiere mai mici

RU: Разделить initrd на более мелкие файлы

VI: Tách initrd thành các tệp nhỏ hơn

Post an answer

Most people don’t grasp that asking a lot of questions unlocks learning and improves interpersonal bonding. In Alison’s studies, for example, though people could accurately recall how many questions had been asked in their conversations, they didn’t intuit the link between questions and liking. Across four studies, in which participants were engaged in conversations themselves or read transcripts of others’ conversations, people tended not to realize that question asking would influence—or had influenced—the level of amity between the conversationalists.