Score:18

Why is it not recommended to install Windows after Ubuntu for dual-boot?

in flag

I know the process is a little bit more complicated in this direction, and grub has to be updated and/or repaired after installing Windows. Is there another reason, besides the more complicated installation process, that it is not recommended to install Windows on existing Ubuntu? Does it lead to stability issues or anything once the installation is completed?

francois P avatar
it flag
just because it is linux installation who is doing windows & other OS's detection & generates choice menu for boot procedure, Windows isn't able to do that.
cn flag
That WAS the case before UEFI. Nowadays not too important. "Does it lead to stability issues or anything once the installation is completed?" No.
crip659 avatar
pl flag
Think it was done for the people are were new to installing OSs. It took one minor pain in the neck problem out of the process(for people used to it).
raj avatar
cn flag
raj
I think it is rarely needed to install Windows alongside Ubuntu for dual-boot. Usually Windows is either preinstalled on the machine or someone who already used Windows wants to switch to Linux, so installing Ubuntu alongside Windows for dual-boot makes sense. However, if someone who already uses Ubuntu wants/needs Windows, he/she will probably install Windows in a virtual machine rather than for dual-boot.
ag flag
@francoisP Windows could if Microsoft would, but it is not in their interest to make that easier.
ag flag
@raj, one word: "games" - they don't run well in a virtual machine.
francois P avatar
it flag
Absoluly right @ThorbjørnRavnAndersen
Score:32
cn flag

It is possible for sure to install Windows after Linux, and once everything is set up, it technically does not make any difference which OS was installed first. The only reason it is recommended to install Windows first is because the latter is a bit more easy.

  • If you install Windows after Linux, your system will not display the Grub menu, but directly boot into Windows: you will have no access to the Ubuntu installation. It requires extra actions to restore displaying the Grub menu again. With legacy boot mode, users were required to reinstall Grub. With UEFI boot mode, which is standard nowadays, it is sufficient to change the bootorder in BIOS to the Ubuntu system. Still, this is an extra technical hurdle to users.
  • If you install Linux after Windows, the Grub menu is automatically set up. The user has access to any operating system that is installed on the computer without extra interventions. Thus, it is easier for technically less proficient users.
Pentaquark avatar
in flag
Thank you for your answer. Regarding re-installing grub, I have read contradictory accounts: Some guides like this one (https://itsfoss.com/install-windows-after-ubuntu-dual-boot/) claim updating grub via `sudo update-grub` does the trick, while others like this one (https://www.alphr.com/install-windows-10-alongside-ubuntu/) claim that boot-repair is needed to get it back. Would you mind weighing in on this?
Pentaquark avatar
in flag
Ok, it appears the difference lies in EFI. If an EFI System is present, updating grup should be sufficient. Did I understand that correctly?
cc flag
The Linux install puts two copies of the grub bootloaders onto the EFI partition: 1)under .../EFI/ubuntu/shimx64.efi and 2)under .../EFI/Boot/bootx64.efi. An nvram entry is made for the ...ubuntu entry, so simply rearranging the bootorder may be sufficient to boot grub first again. However, if your boot is off the device default in .../EFI/Boot, then the bootx64.efi may have been overwritten by a Windows bootloader.
phuclv avatar
sd flag
there's no bootloader in UEFI so the first point is moot nowadays
mangohost

Post an answer

Most people don’t grasp that asking a lot of questions unlocks learning and improves interpersonal bonding. In Alison’s studies, for example, though people could accurately recall how many questions had been asked in their conversations, they didn’t intuit the link between questions and liking. Across four studies, in which participants were engaged in conversations themselves or read transcripts of others’ conversations, people tended not to realize that question asking would influence—or had influenced—the level of amity between the conversationalists.